Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout09-21-1998The original architectural character has been irrevocably altered by the additions. Disfmctive features have been removed (a). From what can be seen, the original siding, window and door frames have been damaged by installation of the aluminum siding. If the aluminum siding were removed, and not replaced, the original clapboards may have to be replaced and features reconstructed. The amount and quality of original material and design remaining would then be marginal (f). Criteria 3. Proposed new construction. The effect of the work, vinyl siding, on the historic and architectural character of the surrounding buildings and neighborhood will be minimal. All the adjacent properties are non-contributing. HPC Residential Guidelines, Restoration and Rehabilitation, Walls. Sct. B. Vinyl and Aluminum siding. (a) In cases where existing aluminum siding is to be removed and where the original siding and decorative features are found to be significantly deteriorated, the commission should conduct a site visit during removal process and advise on appropriate treatment. 1) If vinyl is used it should be appropriate for the width of the building. 2) Window trim, cornice and ornament must remain uncovered. Trim must be built up so that it projects from the new siding to the same extent as the original. 3) Replacment siding may cover only one layer of existing siding. These treatments will be followed by the owner. (c) The siding of new garages on protected properties with artificial materials may be approved by the commission on a case by case basis. In this case the siting, design and siding of the garage are considered compatible with the surrounding buildings and the neighborhood. After discussion, the motion was carded, 5 for, 1 opposed. 3. Adjournment. Mr. Simacek moved and Ms. Sovik-Siemens seconded adjourment; motion carded. HASTINGS HERITAGE PRESERVATION COMMISSION MINUTES OF MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 15, 1998 1.ROIL Commissioners Thorsen, Coutu, Goderstad, Warg and Simacek present. Mr. Thorsen called the meeting to order at 7 p.m. 2. Review of building permits or design proposals. a. 208 Second St. E. Bob Bathrick - reconstruct damaged storefront. Contributing, Downtown National Register District. Mr. Goderstand moved and Ms. Coutu seconded approval of the design provided by Mr. Bathrick's contractor, Mr. Swanstrom, based on these findings. First, this is an art deco storefront (late 20s-early 30s') possessing its own significance as the only remaining example of its type in the community and should be preserved (rebuilt after accident). Second, the design for repairing the art glass and replacing the windows, and building a new bulkhead with the entry door in the center, is appropriate for the style of building, and compatible with the adjacent historic buildings. Motion carried, 5-0. b. 521 Tyler - Rick Harrington - vinyl side new garage and if approved, house next year. Non-contributing, Old Hastings Historic District. A~er discussion, Chairman Thorsen asked the I-IPC to meet at the property at 5:30 p.m. on September 21 to view the condition &the wood siding beneath the existing aluminum siding on the house. The key issues to resolve will be the condition of the original material and the amount of original design remaining. 3. Adjournment. Mr. Warg moved and Mr. Goderstad seconded adjournment; motion carried.